Sunday, February 10, 2008

In Defense of Cotillard

Every year at this time, the film bloggers get out their pitchforks and begin to vilify one of the most beloved performances of the year. Last year, they went after my girl J. Hud in Dreamgirls, claiming she couldn't act and claiming all the hoopla was overblown. She got the last laugh by winning the Oscar, but that still didn't stop the nay-sayers. This year, they seem to be gunning after Marion Cotillard's immaculate work in La Vie en Rose, where she IS Edith Piaf.

So what are people saying about Cotillard, you ask? Here are some of the choice words from a few of my "contemporaries" (I use that word loosely because they are generally better than me):

Nathaniel R. at The Film Experience claims that "'Edith Piaf' has no through line, no modulated character development: she's all big moments without connective performance tissue."

Josh R. at Edward Copeland on Film is the harshest of them all, offering many choice barbs: "really more of an extended drag act with subtitles...the voice is pitched somewhere between The Lord of the Rings' Gollum and the cartoon hag in Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs...Cotillard's approach does not suggest anything even remotely resembling that which might be drawn from the recognizable realm of human behavior."

Glenn at Stale Popcorn claims: "Edith Piaf, as played by Marion Cotillard with an assortment of wigs and Amelie impersonations" and he hopes that "the 'omgsheISedithpiaf' campaign will run off the rails."

DL at The Cellar Door simply states: "I unfortunately can't even say the movie's only watchable for Marion Cotillard, because her irksome, overblown performance is half the reason the movie sucks."

While I respect everyone's opinion, all I really have to say "WTF?" to them. Did we really watch the same performance? I understand that the film itself was pretty much a pile of steaming crap, but Cotillard excelled in ways that the film couldn't. The film cuts across between different time periods so often and so confusingly that I really didn't understand Piaf's timeline any better than before the film. But, with Cotillard, I felt like I understood Piaf the woman. I don't know about anyone else, but I was genuinely moved at certain parts of the film and felt for Cotillard/Piaf extraordinarily. I was angry at her selfish mother in the scene in the bar before she's discovered; I was delighted for Piaf at the New Year's party when she was so excited to be around new friends and the promise of the new year; I was distraught during the scene where she runs maniacally through her house screaming for her lover Marcel; and I was about ready to cry tears of joy when the withered, shadow of her former self Piaf finds her last great hit "Non, je ne regrette rien" and is excited for the chance to perform it for everyone. She literally takes us on a rollercoaster throughout the film (one thing everyone can agree on about this performance is that it's never boring), culminating in that spectacular finale where her performance of "Non, je ne regrette rien" collides with her past, present and future. Her lip syncing is so convincing, so in the moment, that it's hard to wrap my head around the fact that Cotillard isn't actually singing.

A lot of people seem to be convinced that Cotillard overacts in the film (and to some, "overacts" is the understatement of the century). While I do see that she's loud, emotional and messy, I find that it's often for very good reasons. The life of Edith Piaf was not quiet, with just a couple of speed bumps along the way; it was extraordinarily painful with many difficult and awful memories to deal with. This woman is alive and Cotillard is simply reacting to what was happening to Piaf. Her performance is straight out of 1940's Hollywood melodrama and I don't believe it's a stretch to say that Goddesses like Bette Davis and Joan Crawford would have opted to play Piaf like Cotillard.

Let it be heard that I am generally not a huge biopic performance fan. I don't automatically go crazy when some actor or actress de-glams to play a "real" person and proclaim them the Second Coming of Christ for adopting an accent or developing facial tics. Sure, Hoffman in Capote, Witherspoon in Walk the Line and Dame Helen Mirren in The Queen all earned Diva Cup nominations from myself and were generally great performances, but did they deserve to win the Oscar? To quote Whitney Houston, "Hell to tha no!" Even among the nominees, there were generally one or two I liked better. Sonce of the year, you have to realize what a big deal it is when I find a biopic performance that I think should not only win the Oscar, but is also the best performance of the year.

4 comments:

Kamikaze Camel said...

"She literally takes us on a rollercoaster throughout the film"

But that's the character, not the performance. I still say the performance was just overly LOUD and overwrought and broad.

Agreed that the "Non je ne regrette rien" is the film's best moment, but that's the SONG not the PERFORMANCE. I put passion into lipsyncing ever day when I'm dancing around my bedroom, but I'm not Oscar-worthy.

(I was and still am a fan of J.Hud's Dreamgirls perf though)

a random visitor said...

Her detractors aren't nearly as numerous as the REALLY REALLY ANNOYING superfans of hers that insult every other nominee at every turn and say you don't know acting if you don't give her the win(you're not one of them, but you're actually the first Cotillard supporter I've found that's not). Anyway, I totally disagree with this article - I thought she was very showy and terribly empty - but great blog.

Anonymous said...

I'm a fan of her performance. One of the best performances I even see in years, after awful choices of Helen Hunt, Gwyneth Paltrow and Reese Witherspoon (I don't understand how Nathaniel loves that annonying performance, She sings but I'm sorry I watch Reese Witherspoon playing Reese Witherspoon with dark hair. Same actitudes, faces and voice...

marion has the complete transformation and like a chamaleon she doesn't play Edith Piaf, she's Piaf, I compare videos of her and Marion Cotillard, and yes Marion is Piaf not MArion playing Piaf. Sorry detractors but Marion Cotillard deserves the Oscar very well...

Ayesha Magi said...



Pakistani Uncle Fucking Neighbour Coming Into Vagina


Yanomami People Live Very Hard At Amazon


Um dos melhores comerciais já feitos


Yeguada susaeta, cubricion de un caballo


Suits 3x01 Mike & Rachel Bed Scene


Bsc Girls In Class Room in Free Class


Hot North Indian Busty Aunty Fucking With Servant In BathRoom


Mallu Aunty and a Young Boy - Matinee Masala


Gorgeous Amateur Pakistani Girl Fucked By Black Guy


namitha sex video tamil ( தமிழ் வீடியோ )


Girl and Horse - Great Bond


BANG-GAALI - Sex & The City [TBM Short Film +Eng Sub]


Homemade Hotty Indian GF Fucked Hard


Bangladeshi Model & Actress Mahiya mahiSex Scandal


Юрий Спасокукоцкий представляет новый DVD "Для девушек"


Sexy Mathara young girl in the bus looking for sex partner real video


Muslim girls sucking uncut hindu boys dick


Muslim girl nisha khan fucking with Indian Hindu Boy


Irani woman fucked by hindu cock


Desi Girls drink Sperm from Tiny Uncut Desi Hindu Dicks


Indian Hindu girl sucking black african cock


Desi indian college students fucking recorded by hidden cam


Hidden Cam Sex Tape Of Desi Indian Teen Couple Leaked


Mallu Aunty Hot Wet Shower Bath full Skin Naked Scene